Assessment.
This has become a bad word for students and teachers alike, both dreading even
the mention of the word. So much
emphasis is placed on testing and data that sometimes we unfortunately lose sight
of what is most important. To me that is growth, socially, emotionally, and
academically. Teaching to the test has never gotten me very far as a teacher
nor greatly impacted my students in any way. It is boring, rote, definitely not
engaging and usually very quickly forgotten. Why not instead take that same
content and make it fun, exciting and engaging? In my opinion, that is what
learning should be. I get so much more from my students when they are excited
about something, curious and interested. It may take a shift in mindset and Yes,
it may take some more planning but in the end well worth it!
In
researching for more effective and authentic assessments I wanted to share my
favorite as well as a couple of resources that may be beneficial! Notebooks are
my absolute favorite way of assessing students! There
are different types of notebooks, dialogue and interactive, both which would be
beneficial and serve different purposes for my deaf students. Using notebooks to assess students is highly effective and
extremely beneficial. The uses of notebooks are limitless and can be used to
explicitly match your students’ needs and strengths. It gives you the ability
to get to know your students in a personal way and truly assess their knowledge
in an authentic and meaningful way. “Notebooks may be helpful for assessment
purposes, as they contain the totality of work produced by a student. Such data
can be analyzed to track student performance over time, determine particular
content areas or concepts in which the student experiences difficulty, or serve
as a basis for student self-assessment” (Butler & McMunn, 2006). Personally,
I see no greater assessment strategy than that of notebooks. For my deaf and
hard of hearing students with significant language delays I can make these
notebooks individualized to meet each student where they are as learners and
then scaffold their learning. This has the potential to profoundly affect my
students learning and overall language acquisition. Notebooks can meet the needs of my diverse learners by being
visual, providing a place to hold their thinking, a great reference tool,
enhance writing skills, and also be interactive. As a teacher I can use this
assessment both informatively and formatively. This tool will give me great
insight into what my students know and don’t know as well and what they can and
cannot do. My students with little language can still use the notebooks as a
way to increase their language and vocabulary through pictures and inventive
spelling. Students can share their work with others as well, which will enhance
their communication skills. Communication both written and spoken is critical
to student success. Notebooks will definitely enhance my students’ language in
multiple ways. Students will have ownership of their learning and can see how
it improves over time. This type of assessment will enable me to build on my
students’ strengths and aid me in planning appropriate instruction to meet
their diverse, individual needs. Notebooks are an excellent way to
differentiate in order to meet all students’ unique needs.
I would implement interactive notebooks
in all content areas, math, science, social studies, grammar, reading and
writing. Interactive notebooks can provide, “a way
for students to personalize and make meaning of the information presented in
class, a powerful study tool, a working portfolio, appeals to multiple
intelligences, encourages pride in student work” (Jones & Wong, 2009).
Possibilities are limitless! A few examples: maps, charts, pictures,
vocabulary, time lines, cartoons, flip books, poems, songs, sequencing, ABC
activities, inventive spelling, word problems, explanations, and the list goes
on and on. This type of assessment will provide a clear picture of what
knowledge the students have acquired and understand and what gaps need to be
addressed or retaught. Since my students are different grade levels as well as
ability levels this type of assessment gives me the ability to differentiate
and provide students instruction on their level and to meet their individual
needs. Instruction and assessment through interactive notebooks also provides a
visual and concrete form for my students to refer back to. They have the
opportunity to see their growth and to self-assess their work. I like the
interactive aspect as we can add anything to our notebooks to make learning
more meaningful and purposeful. This is truly an authentic assessment.
Dialogue notebooks allow me the
opportunity to focus on my students’ language development in an individualized
manner. I also like the idea of students having the opportunity to share
whatever they would like. This is a student driven notebook and just between
the teacher and student. This is such an excellent tool to get to know your
students personally and allow them to share things they may not in a traditional
setting.
I plan to start
small and then totally restructure my teaching next school year. The positive
implications of using notebooks could completely transform my teaching and my
students learning experience. Coupled with tactile/hands on learning experiences
I expect to see a huge gain in student language development and content
knowledge. Through using the notebooks
students will have more ownership in their own learning, learn how to
self-assess their work, engagement will increase as well as interest, and confidence
will increase as students can show their strengths in their notebooks yet grow
in weak areas.
Resources:
Butler, S. M., & McMunn, N. D.
(2006). A teacher's guide to classroom
assessment: Understanding and using assessment to improve student learning. San Francisco,
CA: Jossey-Bass. ISBN: 9780787978778.
More on notebooks:
List of 60 Assessment strategies:
http://www.stma.k12.mn.us/documents/DW/Q_Comp/FormativeAssessStrategies.pdf
I agree that the word assessment has been turned into a monster to fear rather than held in high regards for its true purpose, to provide information to educators on how to better educate our students by giving them opportunities to show what they have learned. Many times assessments are used to show us what students can't do rather than what they can. By individualizing the notebooks to meet students specific needs, as you discussed above, this allows students to show the knowledge that they have gained in a way that spotlights their achievements.
ReplyDeleteHi Lynette,
ReplyDeleteI agree with you 100% that due to isolated skill and drill types of assessments and the overuse of standardized assessment data, assessment has become a very negatively loaded term in our profession. I also agree with you 100% that using authentic assessments to inform my teaching and to guide my instruction has been the most beneficial element of my teaching practice because while I may know a specific content, if I don't know what my students' know or don't know I am ill equipped at differentiating or targeting their growth. You focused this reflection on the impact of using notebooks as a formative assessment tool and I appreciate the research you used to provide a rationale to support this tool and also the specific examples you provided in the form of both interactive and dialogue notebooks. I would love to support your implementation of these next year.
Sincerely,
Dawn
Thank you Dawn! I would LOVE your support. Any advice, guidance would be greatly appreciated!
Delete